In 2015, concerns were raised about Second Chance Rescue (SCR) in Flagler County. Reports suggested that the rescue asked people to “hide dogs,” and there were ongoing investigations into their practices. A correspondence was sent to Orange County Animal Services (OCAS) to verify the relationship and oversight of SCR, given that Flagler County was investigating them. OCAS responded that they were aware but did not receive any formal documentation. Amy Carotenuto, the executive director at Flagler County Humane Society, reported she had informed OCAS of the investigation and that SCR was over the limit of the number of dogs they were allowed to have, the dogs were not receiving adequate exercise, as required (they were out of the crates only a few minutes a day). Despite these concerns, OCAS did not take action. Examination of SCR’s practices suggested they failed to adequately care for their animals, with evidence of a particular dog’s decline under their care, which improved once transferred to another rescue. The OCAS’s oversight mechanisms, as detailed in their agreement sections, highlight that a more proactive stance could have been taken regarding SCR’s operations.
OCAS response to SCR concerns
The response from OCAS (then Director, Dil Luther):
“Orange County Animal Services was made aware by Flagler Humane Society that Second Chance Rescue was being investigated. Their email was very informal and did not provide information such as reports, etc. As this rescue is contracted with Orange County, we responded to Flagler Humane Society for a copy of any investigation reports, charges being filed, actions being taken, etc. They said there were none at this point- there was nothing to share.
We likely will visit the rescue in the near future, but information provided thus far does not suggest specific violations. Flagler County SO not taking immediate action- or contacting Animal Services- indicates there is not an emergent situation.
We are not in a position to make determinations regarding the internal operations of each rescue partner. They function independently of Animal Services and obviously create their own business model. If someone believes this- or any other group- is functioning outside the law, they should contact the local law enforcement agency for assistance, who will ultimately contact Animal Services.”
SCR Dog Condition
(Below – photo of the dog while under the care of SCR)
(Below – shortly after receiving care through another rescue partner)
OCAS Partner Agreements
Improve OCAS Movement 